Rethinking Dairy Fat: What’s Lost When You Skip the Cream?

   8 min read time

Description

An Argument for the superior nourishing qualities of full-fat dairy

As the saying goes, “Milk, it does the body good”, and why not, after all, it is where all dairy products begin. Dairy foods have a long history of being extremely nourishing for those who can tolerate them. 

They provide food for the microbiome, offer one of the highest-quality sources of protein, have a broad-spectrum fatty acid profile, and are an essential source of fat-soluble micronutrients. 

Furthermore, dairy foods are incredibly versatile, enhancing the flavor, texture, and nutritional profile of anything they are added to. 

However, there has been a long-standing debate about the effects of fats found in dairy products on our health. 

Today's article will argue that full-fat dairy foods are, in fact, better for you than low- or non-fat ones. So, let’s begin. 

What is the specific criterion that defines a dairy food?

In simple terms, dairy foods are products derived and created from the milk of mammals that meet specific standards of fat and moisture content, safety requirements, and a quality nourishment profile that includes protein, calcium, and fat- soluble nutrients. 

This includes milk, butter, cheese, and dairy-based desserts. However, products made from milk with high fat and low calcium content, such as cream, sour cream, and cream cheese, are sometimes excluded from the list because they do not meet the specific dairy criteria.   

  • Source: Mammary gland milking animals.
  • Composition: Specific regulating standards, like a minimum 3.25% milk fat, 8.25% non-fat solids, and specific cheeses having a maximum of 38% moisture.
  • Minimal processing standards to ensure safety, including pasteurization. 
  • Nutrient profile: protein, calcium, and fat-soluble nutrients A& D. 

Non-Fat vs Full-Fat Dairy Foods: The Similarities

1) Dairy foods are a great source of protein

Many foods provide nourishing amounts of high-quality protein; each is unique in its own right. One of the many nutritional qualities of dairy foods is its unique blend of fast-digesting (whey) and slow-digesting (casein) proteins, allowing for optimal use of this essential macronutrient. 

It is generally accepted that cottage cheese and Greek yogurt are the best sources of these essential proteins. 

The following was stated in an article in the National Library of Medicine titled Health-Related Aspects of Milk Proteins (opens in a new tab):

  • Casein and whey protein are the major proteins of milk. 
  • Casein constitutes approximately 80% of the total protein in bovine milk, and whey protein accounts for about 20%. 
  • Casein is primarily phosphate-conjugated and forms phosphate micelle complexes. It is a heterogeneous family of 4 major components: alpha (As1 & 2 casein), beta-, gamma-, and kappa-casein.” 
  • Whey protein is a collector of globular proteins with a high level of a-helix structure. 
  • The acidic, basic, and hydrophobic-hydrophilic amino acids are distributed in a fairly balanced form. 
  • Alpha-Lactalbumin and beta-lactoglobulin are the predominant whey proteins. 
  • Among other types of whey proteins, immunoglobulins, serum albumin, lactoferrin, lactoperoxidase, and protease-peptones must be mentioned. 

2) Many wholesome dairy products are available fresh or as a powdered product

While it is best to consume dairy products in their wholesome, fresh form, the idea that we can’t replace fresh food with a powder to nourish our bodies is simply untrue. Fresh foods (especially dairy) have a short shelf life, and their need to be refrigerated limits their versatility. 

As we have mentioned in many of our previous articles and product descriptions, powdered functional superfoods are tremendously versatile, capable of creating new and exciting products and offering unique advantages over their fresh counterparts. There are many significant advantages to using powders, especially dairy products. 

3) The vast majority of dairy products we consume are pasteurized and, in specific cases, homogenized 

  • Pasteurization is considered a food safety process that uses mild heat to destroy pathogens and spoilage enzymes, extending the shelf life of dairy products and juices. With this process, temperature is the key: High temp/short term is 161 degrees for 15 seconds, Ultra high temp is at 275 degrees for 5 seconds, allowing for shelf stabilization; and batch is 145 degrees for 30 seconds. While this process kills pathogenic bacteria, it does not destroy all bacterial spores. Therefore, it is not true sterilization, and the product still requires refrigeration. 
  • Homogenization is a mechanical process that uses heat and pressure to break down fat globules, preventing them from clumping together and rising to the top (aka separation). It ensures the cream remains suspended in the milk, creating a uniform texture. This was evident back in the day, when fresh milk was delivered to people's homes in glass bottles, and you could literally see the separation.

4) All dairy foods go through some processing

Before going into detail about how all dairy foods, to some extent, are processed, it is essential to understand the various levels of processing most foods go through.

There are four primary categories for classifying processed food. 

  • Unprocessed: Single-ingredient food and beverages that have undergone no modification, where the beneficial nutrients are still intact. In simple terms, think of an orange, an apple, or a banana.
  • Minimally processed: A single-ingredient food that has undergone some form of processing. However, the form or processing does not compromise the food's overall nutritional integrity. For example, cooking a whole egg is a form of processing. While the cooking process denatures the protein, the egg remains nutritionally intact, providing a complete protein source and a rich micronutrient profile. The cooking process in this case is necessary to prevent Salmonella. 
  • Moderately processed: In this situation, other ingredients, such as salt and sugar, are added to the mix, as in bread and pasta. It is universally agreed that no more than five ingredients went into creating this food. Some people believe that an above-average amount of the nourishing qualities remains intact. However, with a few exceptions, such as fresh bread and pasta, I disagree.  
  • Ultra-processed: These products are so far removed from their original, wholesome state that they should no longer be considered food. They contain a long list of ingredients used to preserve, stabilize, and enhance their taste, creating an addiction to those foods. While highly processed foods may provide some nutrients, they offer little nourishing value compared to whole, wholesome foods. 

While no dairy foods are considered ultra-processed, the vast majority fall under minimally processed (full-fat dairy) or moderately processed (non-fat dairy) because, unless you are consuming raw dairy, as stated above, all dairy foods in many countries undergo Pasteurization and, if necessary, Homogenization. 

Furthermore, some of the healthiest dairy foods we consume are fermented, such as yogurt and certain cheeses (which, by technical definition, are processed foods), because they feed our gut microbiome.  

The not-so “dirty secret” about non-fat dairy foods: Why full-fat dairy is the better choice. 

While it is true that even non-fat dairy foods are a great source of protein and calcium, these types of dairy foods have pitfalls. The vast majority of the pitfalls stem from the removal of the nourishing fats, which provide a great fatty acid profile. Removing the naturally occurring healthy fats in milk products reduces satiety and can lead to overeating. 

Furthermore, products of this nature are often supplemented with sugar, fillers, and refined carbohydrates, providing empty calories with no nourishing benefits. 

Finally, removing fat limits the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins (A and D). It eliminates beneficial components of the milk fat membrane.

Furthermore, contrary to previous beliefs, studies show that full-fat dairy does not increase cardiovascular risk. In fact, the overwhelming evidence for increased cardiovascular risk and obesity points to the empty calories (sugars and refined carbohydrates) added to low-fat dairy. Below is one of many examples.  

The following was stated in a mid-1980s study (opens in a new tab) that tracked participants for over 25 years and examined how different types of dairy affected (CAC), coronary artery calcification.

  • Participants who consumed the most whole-fat dairy had a 24% lower risk of developing CAC compared with those who consumed the least.
  • According to Ethan Cannon, SPH researcher and lead author, people who regularly consumed whole-fat dairy in young adulthood actually showed fewer signs of early heart disease decades later.  
  • While nutritionists have long been concerned about the saturated fat in whole-fat dairy, our research serves as a reminder that the overall effects of a food are not equivalent to those of its individual nutrients. 
  • In the case of whole-fat dairy, the drawback of higher blood cholesterol caused by saturated fat may be outweighed by the benefits of the unique blend of nutrients and other constituents also found in dairy.”

The fats in whole dairy are highly complex and provide the body with substantial nourishment. Although milk fat is often not consumed on its own, it has been given a bad rap. As more is learned about food science, our understanding of how these fats function in the body takes on new meaning. 

According to a review titled Composition, structure, and absorption of milk lipids: a source of energy, fat-soluble nutrients, and bioactive molecules, 

“Milkfat is not only a source of bioactive lipid components, but it also serves as an important delivery medium for nutrients, including the fat-soluble vitamins. Bioactive lipids in milk include triacylglycerides, diacylglycerides, saturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids, and phospholipids.”

“Among the 12 major milk fatty acids, only three (lauric, myristic, and palmitic) have been associated with raising total cholesterol levels in plasma, but their individual effects are variable, both towards raising low-density lipoproteins and raising the level of beneficial high-density lipoproteins. 

The cholesterol-modifying response of individuals to consuming saturated fats is also variable.” Therefore, milkfat's composition, functions, and biological properties will need to be re-evaluated as the food marketplace moves increasingly towards more personalized diets.” 

The breakdown of fatty acids in whole milk:

  • 62% Saturated
  • 30% Monounsaturated
  • 4% Polyunsaturated
  • 4% Transfats

Furthermore, did you know that not all Trans Fatty Acids (TFA) are created equal?

There are two major types of trans fats in the food supply:

  • Industrial: Formed by partial hydrogenation of vegetable oils
  • Natural occurring: Trans fatty acids in milk and meat that are created by biohydrogenation by ruminant animals create (R-TFA). Naturally occurring trans fatty acids include vaccenic acid, the main TFA in dairy, and rumenic acid, the biologically active form of CLA (conjugated linoleic acid). 

In conclusion, the purpose of this article was to debunk the myths that fat-free or low-fat dairy products are superior to their full-fat counterparts or that full-fat dairy products are unhealthy and create illness based on their fat content. 

While not everyone can tolerate dairy, for those who can, when consumed in a proper serving size for your caloric needs, it is extremely nourishing, providing a great macro- and micronutrient profile. 

However, a key component of dairy's nourishing qualities is its fat content, and, as stated in this article, there is very little evidence that the fatty acid profile in dairy foods causes harm when consumed over an extended period. 

What we also know for a fact is that when you remove any component from a whole food, you don’t receive the full benefits, because something is often compromised. 

In some cases, it may cause more harm than good. Dairy is an excellent example of this, as explained in the “Dirty Secret” section of this article. 

Therefore, if you are able to consume dairy, choose full-fat options (for example, grass-fed Greek yogurt and cottage cheese) and enjoy them in appropriate amounts that fit within your caloric needs.  

For more information about our Whole Milk Powder, go here: Whole Milk Powder

The Author’s Bio
Michael Stuchiner is a Master Herbalist and proud graduate of The School of Natural Healing, and has worked in different areas of this field for over 25 years. He is a retired elite-level powerlifter who competed for 27 years. As an avid international traveler, he is passionate about using medicinal and tonic herbs, as well as foods traditionally found in local markets, in the 35 countries he has visited. Michael brings you his years of experience as a Master Herbalist, traveler, and athlete through the hundreds of articles he has written and his YouTube channel (A Master Herbalist Perspective). He is considered a true educator in this field. For more articles written by Mike, go here: Master Herbalist.

 

An Argument for the superior nourishing qualities of full-fat dairy

As the saying goes, “Milk, it does the body good”, and why not, after all, it is where all dairy products begin. Dairy foods have a long history of being extremely nourishing for those who can tolerate them. 

They provide food for the microbiome, offer one of the highest-quality sources of protein, have a broad-spectrum fatty acid profile, and are an essential source of fat-soluble micronutrients. 

Furthermore, dairy foods are incredibly versatile, enhancing the flavor, texture, and nutritional profile of anything they are added to. 

However, there has been a long-standing debate about the effects of fats found in dairy products on our health. 

Today's article will argue that full-fat dairy foods are, in fact, better for you than low- or non-fat ones. So, let’s begin. 

What is the specific criterion that defines a dairy food?

In simple terms, dairy foods are products derived and created from the milk of mammals that meet specific standards of fat and moisture content, safety requirements, and a quality nourishment profile that includes protein, calcium, and fat- soluble nutrients. 

This includes milk, butter, cheese, and dairy-based desserts. However, products made from milk with high fat and low calcium content, such as cream, sour cream, and cream cheese, are sometimes excluded from the list because they do not meet the specific dairy criteria.   

  • Source: Mammary gland milking animals.
  • Composition: Specific regulating standards, like a minimum 3.25% milk fat, 8.25% non-fat solids, and specific cheeses having a maximum of 38% moisture.
  • Minimal processing standards to ensure safety, including pasteurization. 
  • Nutrient profile: protein, calcium, and fat-soluble nutrients A& D. 

Non-Fat vs Full-Fat Dairy Foods: The Similarities

1) Dairy foods are a great source of protein

Many foods provide nourishing amounts of high-quality protein; each is unique in its own right. One of the many nutritional qualities of dairy foods is its unique blend of fast-digesting (whey) and slow-digesting (casein) proteins, allowing for optimal use of this essential macronutrient. 

It is generally accepted that cottage cheese and Greek yogurt are the best sources of these essential proteins. 

The following was stated in an article in the National Library of Medicine titled Health-Related Aspects of Milk Proteins (opens in a new tab):

  • Casein and whey protein are the major proteins of milk. 
  • Casein constitutes approximately 80% of the total protein in bovine milk, and whey protein accounts for about 20%. 
  • Casein is primarily phosphate-conjugated and forms phosphate micelle complexes. It is a heterogeneous family of 4 major components: alpha (As1 & 2 casein), beta-, gamma-, and kappa-casein.” 
  • Whey protein is a collector of globular proteins with a high level of a-helix structure. 
  • The acidic, basic, and hydrophobic-hydrophilic amino acids are distributed in a fairly balanced form. 
  • Alpha-Lactalbumin and beta-lactoglobulin are the predominant whey proteins. 
  • Among other types of whey proteins, immunoglobulins, serum albumin, lactoferrin, lactoperoxidase, and protease-peptones must be mentioned. 

2) Many wholesome dairy products are available fresh or as a powdered product

While it is best to consume dairy products in their wholesome, fresh form, the idea that we can’t replace fresh food with a powder to nourish our bodies is simply untrue. Fresh foods (especially dairy) have a short shelf life, and their need to be refrigerated limits their versatility. 

As we have mentioned in many of our previous articles and product descriptions, powdered functional superfoods are tremendously versatile, capable of creating new and exciting products and offering unique advantages over their fresh counterparts. There are many significant advantages to using powders, especially dairy products. 

3) The vast majority of dairy products we consume are pasteurized and, in specific cases, homogenized 

  • Pasteurization is considered a food safety process that uses mild heat to destroy pathogens and spoilage enzymes, extending the shelf life of dairy products and juices. With this process, temperature is the key: High temp/short term is 161 degrees for 15 seconds, Ultra high temp is at 275 degrees for 5 seconds, allowing for shelf stabilization; and batch is 145 degrees for 30 seconds. While this process kills pathogenic bacteria, it does not destroy all bacterial spores. Therefore, it is not true sterilization, and the product still requires refrigeration. 
  • Homogenization is a mechanical process that uses heat and pressure to break down fat globules, preventing them from clumping together and rising to the top (aka separation). It ensures the cream remains suspended in the milk, creating a uniform texture. This was evident back in the day, when fresh milk was delivered to people's homes in glass bottles, and you could literally see the separation.

4) All dairy foods go through some processing

Before going into detail about how all dairy foods, to some extent, are processed, it is essential to understand the various levels of processing most foods go through.

There are four primary categories for classifying processed food. 

  • Unprocessed: Single-ingredient food and beverages that have undergone no modification, where the beneficial nutrients are still intact. In simple terms, think of an orange, an apple, or a banana.
  • Minimally processed: A single-ingredient food that has undergone some form of processing. However, the form or processing does not compromise the food's overall nutritional integrity. For example, cooking a whole egg is a form of processing. While the cooking process denatures the protein, the egg remains nutritionally intact, providing a complete protein source and a rich micronutrient profile. The cooking process in this case is necessary to prevent Salmonella. 
  • Moderately processed: In this situation, other ingredients, such as salt and sugar, are added to the mix, as in bread and pasta. It is universally agreed that no more than five ingredients went into creating this food. Some people believe that an above-average amount of the nourishing qualities remains intact. However, with a few exceptions, such as fresh bread and pasta, I disagree.  
  • Ultra-processed: These products are so far removed from their original, wholesome state that they should no longer be considered food. They contain a long list of ingredients used to preserve, stabilize, and enhance their taste, creating an addiction to those foods. While highly processed foods may provide some nutrients, they offer little nourishing value compared to whole, wholesome foods. 

While no dairy foods are considered ultra-processed, the vast majority fall under minimally processed (full-fat dairy) or moderately processed (non-fat dairy) because, unless you are consuming raw dairy, as stated above, all dairy foods in many countries undergo Pasteurization and, if necessary, Homogenization. 

Furthermore, some of the healthiest dairy foods we consume are fermented, such as yogurt and certain cheeses (which, by technical definition, are processed foods), because they feed our gut microbiome.  

The not-so “dirty secret” about non-fat dairy foods: Why full-fat dairy is the better choice. 

While it is true that even non-fat dairy foods are a great source of protein and calcium, these types of dairy foods have pitfalls. The vast majority of the pitfalls stem from the removal of the nourishing fats, which provide a great fatty acid profile. Removing the naturally occurring healthy fats in milk products reduces satiety and can lead to overeating. 

Furthermore, products of this nature are often supplemented with sugar, fillers, and refined carbohydrates, providing empty calories with no nourishing benefits. 

Finally, removing fat limits the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins (A and D). It eliminates beneficial components of the milk fat membrane.

Furthermore, contrary to previous beliefs, studies show that full-fat dairy does not increase cardiovascular risk. In fact, the overwhelming evidence for increased cardiovascular risk and obesity points to the empty calories (sugars and refined carbohydrates) added to low-fat dairy. Below is one of many examples.  

The following was stated in a mid-1980s study (opens in a new tab) that tracked participants for over 25 years and examined how different types of dairy affected (CAC), coronary artery calcification.

  • Participants who consumed the most whole-fat dairy had a 24% lower risk of developing CAC compared with those who consumed the least.
  • According to Ethan Cannon, SPH researcher and lead author, people who regularly consumed whole-fat dairy in young adulthood actually showed fewer signs of early heart disease decades later.  
  • While nutritionists have long been concerned about the saturated fat in whole-fat dairy, our research serves as a reminder that the overall effects of a food are not equivalent to those of its individual nutrients. 
  • In the case of whole-fat dairy, the drawback of higher blood cholesterol caused by saturated fat may be outweighed by the benefits of the unique blend of nutrients and other constituents also found in dairy.”

The fats in whole dairy are highly complex and provide the body with substantial nourishment. Although milk fat is often not consumed on its own, it has been given a bad rap. As more is learned about food science, our understanding of how these fats function in the body takes on new meaning. 

According to a review titled Composition, structure, and absorption of milk lipids: a source of energy, fat-soluble nutrients, and bioactive molecules, 

“Milkfat is not only a source of bioactive lipid components, but it also serves as an important delivery medium for nutrients, including the fat-soluble vitamins. Bioactive lipids in milk include triacylglycerides, diacylglycerides, saturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids, and phospholipids.”

“Among the 12 major milk fatty acids, only three (lauric, myristic, and palmitic) have been associated with raising total cholesterol levels in plasma, but their individual effects are variable, both towards raising low-density lipoproteins and raising the level of beneficial high-density lipoproteins. 

The cholesterol-modifying response of individuals to consuming saturated fats is also variable.” Therefore, milkfat's composition, functions, and biological properties will need to be re-evaluated as the food marketplace moves increasingly towards more personalized diets.” 

The breakdown of fatty acids in whole milk:

  • 62% Saturated
  • 30% Monounsaturated
  • 4% Polyunsaturated
  • 4% Transfats

Furthermore, did you know that not all Trans Fatty Acids (TFA) are created equal?

There are two major types of trans fats in the food supply:

  • Industrial: Formed by partial hydrogenation of vegetable oils
  • Natural occurring: Trans fatty acids in milk and meat that are created by biohydrogenation by ruminant animals create (R-TFA). Naturally occurring trans fatty acids include vaccenic acid, the main TFA in dairy, and rumenic acid, the biologically active form of CLA (conjugated linoleic acid). 

In conclusion, the purpose of this article was to debunk the myths that fat-free or low-fat dairy products are superior to their full-fat counterparts or that full-fat dairy products are unhealthy and create illness based on their fat content. 

While not everyone can tolerate dairy, for those who can, when consumed in a proper serving size for your caloric needs, it is extremely nourishing, providing a great macro- and micronutrient profile. 

However, a key component of dairy's nourishing qualities is its fat content, and, as stated in this article, there is very little evidence that the fatty acid profile in dairy foods causes harm when consumed over an extended period. 

What we also know for a fact is that when you remove any component from a whole food, you don’t receive the full benefits, because something is often compromised. 

In some cases, it may cause more harm than good. Dairy is an excellent example of this, as explained in the “Dirty Secret” section of this article. 

Therefore, if you are able to consume dairy, choose full-fat options (for example, grass-fed Greek yogurt and cottage cheese) and enjoy them in appropriate amounts that fit within your caloric needs.  

For more information about our Whole Milk Powder, go here: Whole Milk Powder

The Author’s Bio
Michael Stuchiner is a Master Herbalist and proud graduate of The School of Natural Healing, and has worked in different areas of this field for over 25 years. He is a retired elite-level powerlifter who competed for 27 years. As an avid international traveler, he is passionate about using medicinal and tonic herbs, as well as foods traditionally found in local markets, in the 35 countries he has visited. Michael brings you his years of experience as a Master Herbalist, traveler, and athlete through the hundreds of articles he has written and his YouTube channel (A Master Herbalist Perspective). He is considered a true educator in this field. For more articles written by Mike, go here: Master Herbalist.

 

RELATED ARTICLES

FEATURED PRODUCTS